APL投稿经验
整个花了三个月的时间,投的是超表面方向的,当时选择的是介质介电方向。送审的副主编是国立台湾大学的林敏聪,副主编在一审的时候送审了三个审稿人都是拒绝审稿(当时这个第一个版本写得太乱了,这个拒绝审稿有看不懂还有没有时间。这里大家推荐的审稿人如果没有在APL上面发过较多的论文是没有审稿资格的,副主编很少会选择,担心存在关系户什么的)。第一个审稿人花了5天时间审完,第二个审了18天。第一个审稿人估计没啥看懂,然后直接全是yes,第二个审稿人是觉得达到了APL的标准但是物理机理和论文写作英文这些不太行。然后第一个审稿人没有给任何意见,第二个审稿人给了9个意见,每一个都很长,问的问题也都还是挺专业的。回复信都写了13000多字,论文从原来的2300字改到了3200字。虽然论文有点超过3000字的字数但是没有太大问题
一审:
Revised Manuscript Received from Author23-Jul-2021 00:42:43
Waiting for Revised Manuscript from Author30-Jun-2021 08:51:32
Decision Sent to Author30-Jun-2021 08:51:32
Decision Letter Being Prepared30-Jun-2021 08:50:07
Associate Editor Decision Completed30-Jun-2021 08:50:07
Decision Letter Being Prepared30-Jun-2021 04:45:21
Associate Editor Decision Completed30-Jun-2021 04:45:21
Review Received27-Jun-2021 06:37:19
Associate Editor Decision Started27-Jun-2021 06:36:03
All Reviews Received27-Jun-2021 06:36:03
Review Received27-Jun-2021 06:36:03
All Reviewers Secured09-Jun-2021 19:01:17
Review Started09-Jun-2021 19:01:17
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review09-Jun-2021 19:01:17
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent03-Jun-2021 15:49:11
Potential Reviewer Declined to Review02-Jun-2021 21:37:37
Review Received02-Jun-2021 11:30:15
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent28-May-2021 15:34:06
Potential Reviewers Selected28-May-2021 05:32:24
Review Started27-May-2021 02:31:51
First Reviewer Secured27-May-2021 02:31:51
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review27-May-2021 02:31:51
Associate Editor Review26-May-2021 18:02:31
Potential Reviewer Declined to Review26-May-2021 18:02:31
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent26-May-2021 15:58:43
Potential Reviewer Declined to Review26-May-2021 06:05:58
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent24-May-2021 15:31:28
Potential Reviewers Selected23-May-2021 00:59:33
Associate Editor Review21-May-2021 16:37:24
Securing Associate Editor21-May-2021 14:34:59
Securing Editor21-May-2021 14:34:59
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed21-May-2021 14:34:59
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started21-May-2021 09:45:12
Securing Editor21-May-2021 09:45:11
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office21-May-2021 09:45:11
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted21-May-2021 05:42:18
二审:
Revised Manuscript Received from Author02-Aug-2021 06:52:16
Waiting for Revised Manuscript from Author30-Jul-2021 10:15:49
Decision Sent to Author30-Jul-2021 10:15:49
Decision Letter Being Prepared30-Jul-2021 06:29:24
Associate Editor Decision Completed30-Jul-2021 06:29:24
Associate Editor Decision Started29-Jul-2021 10:23:07
All Reviews Received29-Jul-2021 10:23:07
Review Received29-Jul-2021 10:23:07
All Reviewers Secured27-Jul-2021 02:18:52
Review Started27-Jul-2021 02:18:52
First Reviewer Secured27-Jul-2021 02:18:52
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review27-Jul-2021 02:18:52
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent26-Jul-2021 15:18:28
Potential Reviewers Selected24-Jul-2021 03:59:59
Associate Editor Review23-Jul-2021 10:19:59
Securing Associate Editor23-Jul-2021 10:19:59
Securing Editor23-Jul-2021 10:19:59
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed23-Jul-2021 10:19:59
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started23-Jul-2021 01:51:26
Securing Editor23-Jul-2021 01:51:26
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office23-Jul-2021 01:51:25
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted23-Jul-2021
三审直接接受(没有再送审稿人了):
Manuscript Sent to Production03-Aug-2021 14:35:19
Manuscript Ready for Production03-Aug-2021 11:25:31
Decision Sent to Author03-Aug-2021 11:25:31
Decision Letter Being Prepared03-Aug-2021 06:49:25
Associate Editor Decision Completed03-Aug-2021 06:49:25
Associate Editor Review02-Aug-2021 12:11:59
Securing Associate Editor02-Aug-2021 12:11:59
Securing Editor02-Aug-2021 12:11:58
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed02-Aug-2021 12:11:58
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started02-Aug-2021 07:24:36
Securing Editor02-Aug-2021 07:24:36
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office02-Aug-2021 07:24:36
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted02-Aug-2021 06:52:16