otherwise在从句中与虚拟语气搭配使用的问题

一个本来很简单的问题被你搞的这么复杂。如果你查一下词典关于副词otherwise的释义,你就会知道otherwise有三种用法,其中之一就是用来表示如果前面所说的事情没发生,或者情况不是前面所说的那样,结果会如何。常可将otherwise理解为一个条件状语从句,if not. 例如:

My parents lent me the money. Otherwise, I couldn't have afforded the trip.

= If my parents hadn't lent me the money, I coouldn't have afforded the trip.

Shut the window, otherwise it'll get too cold in here.

= If you don't shut the window, it'll get too cold in here.

从以上例句可知,otherwise隐含否定意义,相当于一个条件状语从句,但主句并没有否定意义,主句是根据这个否定条件句推理出的结果。

网友的句子均属于otherwise的这种用法。分析如下:

This might sound small, but to undo the effects of such a decrease a candidate would need 30 more GMAT points than would otherwise have been necessary.

这个句子中的than比较分句为than后接谓语动词。网友对这个than比较分句理解有误,才产生了疑问。

首先我解释一下than分句。我换一个结构相同但更为简单的句子说明问题。

几乎所有语法书都认为than引导比较分句时是连词,不作成分。比较分句除了经常采用缩减形式外,主句比较项的对应项在than从句必须省略。例如:

To travel first class, you will have to pay more money than is otherwise necessary.

than从句缺失了主语,补全后的比较从句为:

To travel first class, you will have to pay more money than it is otherwise necessary that you should pay.

在这个补全的than从句中,it为形式主语,that从句为真正主语从句,从句谓语should pay后的宾语为主句比较项more money的对应项,必须在than从句中省略,即than从句中的谓语动词pay缺少宾语。(比较分句在结构上是不完整的分句。)

由于比较分句中的that从句在结构上与主句相同,则通常省略that从句和形式主语it,得到than is necessary. 表面上看,than是从句的主语。(有人认为than在从句中作了主语。其实如果认为than是比较代词,在从句中作成分,than为省略了的that从句中的pay的宾语。)

这句话的意思是,你乘坐飞机旅行,必须付一定数额的机票钱。如果你乘坐头等舱,你要付的钱比如果不坐头等舱时必须付的钱要多。因此:

To travel first class, you will have to pay more money than is otherwise necessary.

= To travel first class, you will have to pay more money than it is necessary that you should pay if you don't travel ffirst class.

由此可以看出,otherwise含有否定意义,但than从句本身还是肯定意义。即than从句的肯定还是否定不因otherwise的使用而改变。.

现在看网友的句子:

This might sound small, but to undo the effects of such a decrease a candidate would need 30 more GMAT points than would otherwise have been necessary.

=This might sound small, but to undo the effects of such a decrease a candidate would need 30 more GMAT points than it would have been necessary that he should need if it had not been for the effects of such a decrease. .

可见,虽然otherwise还有否定意义,但其表示的是一个否定条件,than从句本身还是一个肯定句而不是否定句。因此不能用否定词替换otherwise,otherwise也并非语法上的否定词。

They support the services that would otherwise be uneconomical.

= They support the services that would be uneconomical without their support.

= If they don't support the services, these services would be uneconomical.

显然,otherwise含有否定条件的意义。

With the teacher's help, I found many errors that would otherwise have been overlooked.

= I found many errors that would have been overlooked without the teacher's help.

= I found many errors that would have been overlooked if the teacher had not helped me.

很明显,otherwise表示的是否定条件。

Well-educated people make more money than they would otherwise do.

= Well-educated people make more money than they would do if you were not well-educated.

otherwise还是if not的意思,表示一个否定条件。

从以上例句可以看出,只要你将otherwise理解为一个否定条件,otherwise修饰的谓语(无论肯定还是否定)为在这个否定条件基础上推理出来的结果,一切问题都消失了。非常简单的一个问题。

(0)

相关推荐